Editorial illustration of a village water point.
Karnataka’s department reported Hebbal, a village in Shirahatti taluk of Gadag district, under Har Ghar Jal. When auditors and officials inspected the project in August 2024, the overhead tank was unfinished. The Comptroller and Auditor General linked the unfinished works to 477 households going without water from the project. A later state response said the tank was complete and some pipe and connections remained. CAG audit of Karnataka’s Jal Jeevan Mission, paragraph 3.3.1.
What the government procured
The June 2021 contract, valued at ₹148.04 lakh, provided for 477 household connections as part of a project with pipes and an overhead tank. The progress record dated 31 July 2024 listed 980 metres of pipe and 50 connections still outstanding. In August, the joint inspection found the tank unfinished. The audit’s finding concerns service from the project during the period it examined. Households could have relied on other sources.
What the state said changed
In its May 2025 reply, the state said the tank had been completed as of 8 April 2025, with 200 metres of pipe and 20 connections remaining. It said certification would follow completion and a trial. That answer gives a subsequent construction milestone and quantifies the outstanding work. A trial record, certification and evidence of supply to households would establish when the system began delivering water.
Which office can answer which question?
| Question | Record to check |
|---|---|
| Who accepted the contractor’s progress? | Measurement books, progress certificates and payment bills held by the implementing division. |
| When did the village acquire its reported status? | The entry history and supporting record held by the reporting authority. |
| Did a working system reach all households? | The trial and commissioning records, connection list and service logs. |
| Who handles a failure after commissioning? | The handover document and operations and maintenance agreement. |
What the audit can establish
The audit documents a gap between the status reported and the projects works seen on inspection. The state’s reply describes progress and sets out when certification was expected. The records that could establish whether the gap closed are the dated trial, commissioning and supply records. A household verification round could then test whether supply reached homes consistently.
Based on the CAG audit and the state response reproduced in it. Current supply has not been independently checked at households.
